Applications / Experiments read through FDT

Two cones of one titanium atom

Hester G. Vennema, Cristina Mier, Evert W. Stolte, Leonard Edens, Jinwon Lee and Sander Otte add a second radio-frequency tone to electron spin resonance in a scanning tunnelling microscope, an electron–nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) scheme, and drive and read the nuclear spin of one ⁴⁷Ti atom on an oxygen site of bilayer MgO on Ag(100) at 0.4 K. The heights of the electron’s six resonance peaks read the nucleus’s populations. Two NMR features, near 50 and 85 MHz, are observed at every field of the study from 200 to 1400 mT; the record fits a hyperfine term of 132.4 ± 0.4 MHz and a quadrupole term of −2.9 ± 0.8 MHz, obtains an experimental nuclear g-factor of 0.37 ± 0.04 from the slope of the lines against the field, beside the 0.315 measured in bulk, and determines the signs of both terms. FDT reads the applied field, the tip’s field and the electron’s field at the nucleus as helical density gradients of the omnium, twists in which the two closed patterns hold their moments; the quadrupole term as the tide the nucleus’s skin reads against its own centre path; and each driven or pumped step as a settlement of the state it starts from. In the analysis’s reading, with four readings carried beside the core, the nucleus is read on the interior cone of its two-chart atlas and the electron on the exterior cone, the two meeting at the skin with opposite spin. On the record’s own inputs FDT returns its line positions: the two lines of one nuclear step sum to the hyperfine term, 131.9 ± 0.3 MHz in the deposited spectra, and the electron’s field at the nucleus is −23 ± 3 T, antiparallel to the applied field, an identity map that corroborates no invariant. Five tests follow: helical molecules brought beside ⁴⁷Ti atoms and beside titanium atoms without nuclear spin, read for a field the geometry establishes; ⁴⁹Ti against ⁴⁷Ti on one site, read for a density-channel departure of the hyperfine term and of the outer resonance; and one driven nuclear step read shot by shot in both directions, for two settlements that differ.

The record

What the article reports

The record studies titanium atoms, each carrying an electronic spin of 1/2, adsorbed onto oxygen binding sites of bilayer MgO grown on Ag(100), under the tip of a scanning tunnelling microscope made spin-polarized by picking up 10 to 20 iron atoms. A magnetic field applied perpendicular to the surface lifts the electron’s spin degeneracy, a radio-frequency voltage on the tunnel junction drives electron spin resonance (ESR), and the spin-dependent tunnelling current reads the resonance as a change of the magnetoresistance. On the ⁴⁷Ti isotope, of nuclear spin 5/2, the record resolves six ESR peaks from the hyperfine splitting of the electron’s levels, where titanium isotopes without nuclear spin show a single peak. The relative peak heights, it writes, correspond directly to the time-averaged occupation probability of each nuclear spin state, and their unbalanced distribution indicates nuclear spin polarization by inelastic electron scattering mediated by the hyperfine interaction. All measurements are carried out at a sample temperature of 0.4 K, and every main-text spectrum but the single-tone low-field set comes from one microtip.

To calculate the transition energies the record uses an effective spin Hamiltonian, its Eq. (1): the electron’s Zeeman term, its splitting with contributions from the external field and from the field of the spin-polarized tip; the nuclear Zeeman term, the tip’s contribution to it neglected as below the energy resolution; and the hyperfine and quadrupole tensors, whose diagonal terms enter the energy calculation, with the Bohr and nuclear magnetons printed as 13.99 GHz/T and 7.62 MHz/T. At sufficiently large field the electron Zeeman energy, ∼1–10 GHz, dominates the hyperfine energy, ∼100 MHz, the quadrupole energy, ∼10 MHz, and the nuclear Zeeman energy, ∼1–10 MHz, and the record describes the system as a product state of the two spin projections. At low field, sweeping around half the hyperfine energy, ∼65 MHz, single-tone spectra show features resembling NMR transitions; there, the record writes, the two projections are not good quantum numbers, the eigenstates are hybrid states, and the magnetoresistive readout, an electron spin projective measurement, sees transitions that involve the electron spin. The features vanish with rising field and are absent at 200 mT, where the relevant hybridization term is strongly reduced.

To separate driving from readout the record runs two radio-frequency sources at once, one in the GHz range for ESR and one in the MHz range for NMR. The ESR tone sits on one ESR peak, whose height reads one nuclear state’s population, while the NMR tone is swept. At 450 mT, with the NMR tone off resonance at 30.2 MHz, the typical distribution returns; on resonance, at 49.3 MHz, the first two ESR peaks equalize in height, which the record takes to imply that the drive saturates the two nuclear spin populations. Two features, near 50 and 85 MHz, are attributed to the nuclear step from −5/2 to −3/2 with the electron’s spin down and up. With the ESR tone away from any ESR transition the record sees no dependence on the NMR frequency, and on a titanium isotope without nuclear spin no feature in this range. A map over both frequencies resolves at least two pairs of transitions, the steps from −5/2 to −3/2 and from −3/2 to −1/2 for each electron state, the quadrupole contribution lifting the two of a pair apart; a third pair, from −1/2 to +1/2, whose splitting is the nuclear Zeeman energy alone, the record names as one that can be discerned. The four remaining transitions were not measured, the ESR signals of the +1/2 and +3/2 states being low under a nuclear spin polarization preferring −5/2. From the fit the record finds a hyperfine term 𝒜zz = 132.4 ± 0.4 MHz, consistent with previous studies, and a quadrupole term 𝒬zz = −2.9 ± 0.8 MHz, a deviation of ∼5% from previous reports that it proposes to attribute to a different electric field gradient dependent on the tip shape.

Across seven fields from 200 to 1400 mT, where the hybridization between the electron and nuclear spins is reduced by approximately a factor of 10, the ESR tone set to the first ESR peak, the features labelled I and II are observed for all fields, and a second pair, III and IV, near 65 and 75 MHz, for all fields except 1400 mT. Driving III and IV also lowers the population of −5/2, which the record understands as reduced spin pumping towards that state. From the slope of the fitted positions against the field it obtains an experimental nuclear g-factor of 0.37 ± 0.04, which differs slightly from the literature value of 0.315 measured in bulk. With rising field the inner features III and IV become less pronounced, which the record ties to reduced hybridization lowering the flip-flop rate, and the higher-energy features II and IV fall, consistent with their assignment to the electron’s up state. ENDOR at ESR amplitudes of 6, 12 and 19 mV, at 450 mT, shows the population ratio of the two electron states approaching 1 as the amplitude rises, which the record takes to remove the ambiguity about which transitions belong to the electron’s ground state. Its radio-frequency line could not send a constant amplitude to all ESR frequencies, especially above 500 mT.

Because the nuclear Zeeman energy is resolved, the NMR transition energies are no longer invariant under a reversal of the hyperfine sign, as the ESR energies are; from the direction of the slope and the confirmed ground state the record determines 𝒜zz > 0, preferring antiparallel orientation of electron and nuclear spins, and 𝒬zz < 0, preferring an in-plane nuclear charge distribution. Of three interactions whose modulation can cause the transitions, it finds hyperfine-mediated flip-flop transitions unlikely, leaves open a radio-frequency modulation of an off-diagonal hyperfine term that preserves the electron’s state, finds a quadrupole modulation not the dominant mechanism, and finds a Zeeman modulation in line with the selection rules but inherently weak. The present measurements, it writes, do not allow strong conclusions on the driving mechanism, and the driving field cannot be quantified. Its outlook is pulsed measurement of the coherence time at high field and weak hybridization, where the nuclear relaxation time is of the order of seconds.

The record’s values, each with the verb the record gives it.
QuantityValueIts verb
ESR peaks, ⁴⁷Ti and isotopes without nuclear spinsix; oneresolve; observed
Setting of the ESR survey4 pA, 80 mV, ESR amplitude 20 mV, 450 mTcaption
NMR tone on and off resonance, 450 mT49.3 MHz; 30.2 MHzequalize in height; recover the typical distribution
NMR features I and II∼50 MHz and ∼85 MHzattributed; observed for all fields
NMR features III and IV∼65 MHz and ∼75 MHzobserve, all fields except 1400 mT
Hyperfine term 𝒜zz132.4 ± 0.4 MHzfit for
Quadrupole term 𝒬zz−2.9 ± 0.8 MHzfind
Experimental nuclear g-factor0.37 ± 0.04obtain, from the slope
Literature value, measured in bulk0.315cited (its Ref. 38)
Bohr and nuclear magnetons13.99 GHz/T; 7.62 MHz/Tprinted
Electron Zeeman, hyperfine, quadrupole and nuclear Zeeman energies∼1–10 GHz, ∼100 MHz, ∼10 MHz, ∼1–10 MHzdominates over
Hybridization, 200 to 1400 mTreduced by approximately a factor of 10is reduced (its SFig. 2)
Single-tone features near 𝒜zz/2∼65 MHz, at 60 and 100 mT; absent at 200 mTreveals; vanish
ESR amplitudes of the power series6, 12 and 19 mV, at 3.8 GHzobtained with
Signs𝒜zz > 0; 𝒬zz < 0determine
Nuclear relaxation time, weak hybridizationof the order of secondscited (its Ref. 33)
Sample temperature0.4 Kcarried out at

The FDT reading

P-⁠5 Fields as twists, I-⁠3a the tide, 0.1a settlements

There is one substance, the omnium: matter, energy and spacetime are three readings of it, and the chain E/m = c² = 1/(ε₀μ₀) = (d/t)² is one state read four ways, settled by one global optimisation and never one term at a time (0.1, 0.1a). c is the strand rate of the omnium, derived from its two responses (0.1d). A magnetic field is a macroscopic helical density gradient of the omnium (P-⁠5). The analysis reads the applied field, the tip’s field and the electron’s field at the nucleus as such gradients, twists, and the two Zeeman terms of the record’s Eq. (1) as the held moments of the electron’s closure and of the nucleus in the twist where each sits. In a twist a pattern takes its own rest energy as its clock factor, the helical window:

E = E₀ + Eind − Σ 𝗆·𝖡tw,   𝓜 = E/c²,   𝔪 = E/E₀the helical window (0.1c)

with 𝗆 the held moments, 𝖡tw the twist’s field where they sit, Eind the induced energy and E₀ the rest energy outside every twist. A uniform twist turns a held moment and pushes nothing (0.1c).

Where the record describes the system as a product state, the step of the nucleus from 𝖨z to 𝖨z + 1, with the electron in the seating 𝖲z, sits to first order at

f(𝖨z → 𝖨z + 1) = |𝔤N𝔟N𝖡app + 𝒜zz𝖲z + 𝒬eff(2𝖨z + 1)|one nuclear step, first order

with 𝒬eff = 3𝒬zz/2 for the trace-free tensor the deposit builds. Lines I and II are one step, from −5/2 to −3/2, read with the electron in its two seatings, a seating being the analysis’s term for a value of a spin projection. Their sum holds the hyperfine term alone, and their difference twice the nucleus’s own Zeeman term and twice the tide’s:

f+ = fI + fII = 𝒜zz,   f− = fII − fI = 2𝔤N𝔟N𝖡app − 8𝒬effone step, two seatings

Over the six four-line fields of the deposited spectra the sum averages 131.9 ± 0.3 MHz beside the fitted 132.4 ± 0.4 MHz, and over the seven fields the six ESR peaks are spaced on average by 132.2 ± 0.5 MHz; line I falls at −2.8 ± 0.3 MHz/T over the seven fields, |𝔤N| = 0.36 ± 0.04 beside the record’s 0.37 ± 0.04. Each is the identity map of Use 2 and corroborates no invariant.

The record’s signs chain to one more number. With the slope’s direction, the electron’s ground state, the convention of Eq. (1), whose nuclear Zeeman term enters with +𝔟N𝔤N, and the ⁴⁷Ti moment of −0.78848 nuclear magnetons, so that 𝔤N = 0.31539 in that convention, the moment antiparallel to the spin, the electron’s field at the nucleus in its ground seating is

𝖡hf = −𝒜zz/(2𝔤N𝔟N)the twist the nucleus sits in

−23 ± 3 T with the record’s 0.37 and −27.6 T with its literature value, 0.315, antiparallel to the applied field: an identity on Eq. (1).

Four readings are carried beside the core, each cited by its id and never stated as the record’s. CI-1: “From the FDT perspective, the outside truncated cone and the inside truncated cone have opposite spin.” CI-2: “The internal magnetic resonance should be the opposite of the external.” CI-3: “Spin changes every time a density boundary is crossed.” CI-4: “A pattern’s spin is the winding sense of its helix about its cone’s axis, its moment the axial dual; like spins grind, opposite spins mesh, for the pairs one settlement joins.” A bound configuration such as a nucleus is carried by two charts, the exterior atlas of the source and the interior chart of the configuration, two truncated density cones meeting apex circle to apex circle at the skin (I-⁠3). The analysis reads the electron’s closure on the exterior cone of the nucleus’s atlas and the nucleus on the interior cone, the skin being the density boundary of CI-3; by CI-1 the two have opposite spin. The datum CI-1 reads is the record’s positive hyperfine term, preferring antiparallel orientation of electron and nuclear spins, and by CI-4 the antiparallel pair is meshed. No derivation of the sign from the two cones is written: it is a held-out target, and no overlap complex is written here (O-⁠5).

By CI-2 the inner resonance is the opposite of the outer. The outer resonance, the centre of the ESR multiplet, rises with the applied field, at 7.88 ± 0.02 GHz/T over the seven fields of the deposit, with 𝔤e = 0.563 ± 0.002 and 66 ± 2 mT of the tip’s field along the normal; the ground-state lines I and III fall. The analysis reads the nucleus in the electron’s twist, so the opposition is the joined pair’s: to first order each ground-state line falls until the applied field at which its position reaches zero, for line I

𝖡cr = (𝒜zz/2 + 6𝒬zz)/(𝔤N𝔟N)line I’s crossing field

17 ± 3 T with the record’s 0.37 and 20 ± 2 T with its literature value. The record’s 0.37 beside 0.315 the analysis reads as the held moment together with the moment the applied field induces, Eind of the helical window; no number is written for an induced part.

A curvature is read between neighbours, and an extended pattern is such a pair across its own bound extent: its skin against its centre path reads the surrounding tide through its l = 2 moment, and the trace there is density (I-⁠3a). The analysis reads the quadrupole term as the nucleus’s l = 2 moment, its skin against its own centre path reading the surrounding tide, the weight its charge; the trace being density, the trace-free form is the tide’s. The tip belongs to the surroundings (0.1a), which is how the analysis reads the record’s attribution of its quadrupole deviation to the tip shape: in the deposit’s setpoint series the difference of lines I and II moves at 0.7 ± 0.4 MHz/pA and their sum at 0.4 ± 0.3 MHz/pA, while the ESR centre moves by 13.9 ± 0.2 mT of the tip’s field along the normal per pA. Every datum about an interior is a profile-weighted mean with its probe weight named (I-⁠3): the hyperfine term is weighted by the electron’s spin density with the nucleus’s magnetization.

A nucleus is one pattern; what a probe reconstructs is that pattern’s response, not a distribution of constituents inside a boundary (0.1b). The analysis reads the six ESR peaks as the joined configuration’s response at six seatings of the nucleus, each an orientation of a closed pattern in the twist it sits in, and the record’s isolation of nuclear spins from their environment stays its word, never a wall around the nucleus. The universe is deterministic, with no probability amplitudes, and the readout is projection and phase fixation (I-⁠4): a time-averaged population is a dwell fraction of one seating at a time, a share and never a curvature ratio (I-⁠6), and the hybridization at low field, in the analysis’s reading, a shared bivector grade. Each NMR line is a precession of the nucleus’s transverse moment at its line frequency, the planar projection of helical transport. Every ENDOR amplitude is a driven observable, which vanishes at zero drive (I-⁠1): under an ESR amplitude that varies with field it fixes no rate without the drive’s calibration.

The global optimisation is solved at every step, from the state the system is in: events do not commute, a process run backward is never the mirror of the forward event, and responses are system-wide and many-to-many (0.1a). Driving lines III and IV lowers the dwell fraction of −5/2, a seating that step does not touch. The record’s saturation, inferred from two equal peak heights, takes, in the analysis’s reading, the two peaks’ responses as equal and a driven step and its reverse as equal; T-⁠5 reads the step and its reverse apart. Across the ground manifold’s 5𝒜zz/2 = 331 ± 1 MHz, 15.89 ± 0.05 mK, the Boltzmann ratio at the sample’s 0.4 K is 0.96: the polarization the record reports is driven. By CI-4 the pumped seating, −5/2, is the like configuration, the ground manifold’s highest seating, its hyperfine term 5𝒜zz/4 = 165.5 ± 0.5 MHz above the manifold’s centre: driven, not settled.

There is one carrier: photon, graviton, gluon, phonon and magnon are the same spin-1 excitation read in different regimes, and the magnon is the stroke through a helical density gradient (I-⁠2). The analysis reads the GHz and MHz tones and the quanta of both resonances as strokes of the one carrier. Mass, energy, pressure and temperature enter one total gravitating energy, every channel once (I-⁠7):

𝓜 = M + E/c² + PV/c² + aT⁴V/c² + …a = 4σSB/c,   Rs = 2G𝓜/c²each channel once

One quantum of line I at 49.3 MHz enters the nucleus’s 𝓜 once, hf/c² = 3.63 × 10⁻⁴³ kg, 4.66 × 10⁻¹⁸ of its rest energy, and the sample’s 0.4 K enters once, through aT⁴V/c².

The record leaves its driving mechanism open. The analysis derives one reading from the record’s own Hamiltonian: a transverse drive on the electron at the NMR frequency tilts the electron’s axis, and the nucleus meets a transverse field 𝔨rel times the drive, odd in the electron’s seating, to leading order

𝔨rel = (𝒜⊥/𝒜zz)(𝔤⊥/𝔤e) |𝖡hf|/(𝖡app + 𝖡tip,z)the electron relays the drive

with 𝒜⊥ the in-plane hyperfine term and 𝔤⊥ the electron’s in-plane g-factor. The exact matrix element, with the deposit’s inputs, is larger at every field: 𝔨rel = 3 × 10¹, 1 × 10¹ and 4 at 200, 450 and 1400 mT, at the one figure of the deposit’s fixed 𝒜⊥ = 10 MHz, and the ratio between 200 and 1400 mT is 5.5 in the leading form and 6.2 in the exact one. It is an operator of the form the record names, 𝒜zx𝖲z𝖨x, derived with inputs the record does not measure: the analysis’s derived reading, never the mechanism established. A Rabi rate is a driven observable read through its response to a calibrated drive (I-⁠1), and the ratio of line I’s Rabi rates at 200 and 1400 mT, under one transverse drive calibrated at the atom that enters Eq. (1) through the electron’s term alone, decides the reading.

X-⁠1, exploratory. CI-1 can be read on the two spins, the antiparallel pair the lower, or on the two moments. ⁴⁷Ti on oxygen satisfies both: its positive hyperfine term prefers antiparallel spins, and its moment, antiparallel to its spin as the electron’s is to its own, leaves the two moments antiparallel too. Hydrogen’s 1s ground state meets the reading on the spins alone, ⁵⁷Fe in iron the reading on the moments alone, and the ³He⁺ ion neither; the direction of the field slope of another adatom’s ground-state NMR line, such as the copper the record names, is where this platform would tell the two apart. X-⁠1 carries no number and is never counted with the tests.

One step, two seatings; inner and outer. The lines: the nucleus’s six seatings with the electron in each of its two, to first order in the record’s Eq. (1) with 𝒜zz = 132.4 MHz, 𝒬zz = −2.9 MHz and 𝒬eff = 3𝒬zz/2, and lines I to IV, the steps from −5/2 to −3/2 and from −3/2 to −1/2; beside them, line positions against the applied field, the first-order lines with the record’s 𝔤N = 0.37 or the bulk 0.315, the deposit’s refitted positions at the seven fields with their errors, and the midpoint of each pair, 𝒜zz/2, which the sum rule fixes at every field. Inner and outer: the outer resonance, the centre of the ESR multiplet from the deposit’s fit, rises at 7.88 GHz/T with 66 mT of the tip’s field; the ground-state lines fall, line I to zero at line I’s crossing field, 17 T with 0.37 and 20 T with 0.315, the opposition CI-2 reads, the excited-state lines rising; the dotted line marks the applied field equal in size to the electron’s field at the nucleus, |𝖡hf|, 23 T with 0.37 and 27.6 T with 0.315, and the tide’s term sets line I’s crossing below it. Every line is the identity map on Eq. (1), and the extension to the crossing field is first order in that same Hamiltonian; the refitted positions are the analysis’s reconstruction from the deposit, never values the record prints.

P-⁠5, 0.1c, I-⁠3a, CI-1, CI-2, Use 2

What FDT predicts

Five tests, each against its comparator

Five tests stand where a core clause supplies what the consensus calculation lacks: P-⁠5’s field in a helical geometry, an additional source, for T-⁠1 and T-⁠2; I-⁠7’s density channel, a constitutive input, for T-⁠3 and T-⁠4; and 0.1a’s two settlements, a changed observable dictionary, for T-⁠5. An atom is a titanium atom on an oxygen site of the record’s bilayer MgO on Ag(100), read as the record reads, at 4 pA, 80 mV and an ESR amplitude of 20 mV, the working field 450 mT, one microtip per design. Each test reads twelve values and decides by an exact sign-flip permutation test, whose null distribution is the set of means from all 2¹² = 4096 sign assignments of the twelve. Two-sided at p ≤ 0.0027 the rule admits the ten most extreme, a size of 10/4096 = 0.0024; one-sided at p ≤ 0.00135, the five most extreme, 5/4096 = 0.0012. Fair coins drawn before each manipulation and reading set every hand, isotope order and reading order, so whatever one atom, site or reading carries takes a sign the coins set, while the leak and the consensus channels are carried by declared bounds: the tests rest on sign symmetry and those bounds, on no variance estimate. The ⁴⁹Ti atoms, the helical molecules, the reversals of field and bias, the single-shot readout and every calibration are the analysis’s design, not measurements in the source.

Two rules recur. The bounded test, for twelve values and a bound 𝔠: the mean lies outside ±𝔠, and the two-sided test of the values, each shifted by 𝔠 against the sign of the mean, rejects at p ≤ 0.0027; with no FDT term its probability is at most 10/4096 wherever the bounded term lies within its bound. The exclusion test, for a scale 𝔥 above 𝔠: a term of magnitude 𝔥 or more is excluded when the mean lies within ±(𝔥 − 𝔠) and the two-sided tests of the values shifted by +(𝔥 − 𝔠) and by −(𝔥 − 𝔠) both reject at p ≤ 0.0027, a false exclusion having probability at most 5/4096 wherever the bounded term lies within its bound. Where a design’s attributed detection and its exclusion both hold, a term of magnitude smaller than its 𝔥 is detected.

  1. T-⁠1
    A helical molecule beside a ⁴⁷Ti atom shifts the electron’s resonance by a field odd in the molecule’s hand, zero in the consensus calculation. Twelve pairs of ⁴⁷Ti atoms and, for each atom, one molecule of a helical, closed-shell hydrocarbon, of the hand + or − as imaged, moved by atom manipulation onto the site a fixed number of lattice sites from the atom along a lattice row in a mirror plane of the support, the two molecules of a pair mirror images in that plane. A fair coin drawn before the manipulation gives one atom of a pair a molecule of the hand + and the other one of the hand −. Each atom is read at the two senses of the applied field along the normal, the tip’s polarization following the field, at the two polarities of the bias and, the tip held at one height, at the bias and at half of it, before its molecule is brought and after; fc, the centre of the atom’s ESR multiplet, is the mean over the two polarities of twice its value at half the bias less its value at the bias, and a coin drawn before each reading sets the order of the two senses. Per atom 𝔡 = ½[fc(+𝖡app) − fc(−𝖡app)], and Δ𝔡 its change on bringing the molecule. Observable: per pair, 𝔶tw = ½[Δ𝔡(+) − Δ𝔡(−)], in units of fcal = 7.88 ± 0.02 MHz, half the change of fc between test fields 1 mT above and below the working field. FDT: by P-⁠5 imposing a physical twist, a helical geometry, on a material is establishing a magnetic field. The mirror in the row’s plane, which contains the normal, reverses the hand and an axial field’s part along the normal and keeps the support, so that part is odd in the hand, and a field the geometry establishes does not reverse with the applied field: 𝔶tw = 𝔤e𝔟e𝖡mol ≠ 0, one sign in every pair, its sense unassigned, with 𝖡mol the field along the normal the molecule of the hand + establishes at the atom. No twist-to-moment kernel is declared, so this is an existence prediction; in units of fcal the contrast reads the field in millitesla. Comparator: zero within the leak. By time reversal for an atom beside a molecule that holds no moment, the ESR frequency at no bias is the same at the two senses of the field once the tip’s polarization has reversed, so 𝔡 holds only the part of the tip’s field that does not reverse and what the current carries even in the bias and not of first order in it. The leak, the difference of the tip’s part between the two atoms of a pair, is bounded by 𝔠tw, fixed before the first contrast is read, and the first contrast is read only with 𝔠tw at or under 0.04 fcal. Detection: the bounded test with 𝔠 = 𝔠tw. Exclusion: the exclusion test with 𝔥tw = 0.1 fcal, which excludes a field of 0.1 mT or more along the normal; otherwise the result is inconclusive.
  2. T-⁠2
    The same shift appears at a titanium atom without nuclear spin, zero in the consensus calculation. Twelve pairs of titanium atoms without nuclear spin, the record’s isotopes with a single ESR peak, with T-⁠1’s molecules, coins, readings and leak bound, fc the position of each atom’s single peak. Observable: 𝔶tw0, defined as 𝔶tw on these atoms. FDT: the twist’s field lands on the electron’s closure whether or not the nucleus holds a moment, so 𝔶tw0 = 𝔤e𝔟e𝖡mol ≠ 0, with no hyperfine term to average: an existence prediction. Comparator: zero within the leak, by T-⁠1’s time reversal. The decision rules are T-⁠1’s, with 𝔥tw = 0.1 fcal.
  3. T-⁠3
    Between ⁴⁹Ti and ⁴⁷Ti on one site the hyperfine term per unit nuclear g-factor departs upward, in the analysis’s reading of I-⁠7’s density-channel input sign. Twelve oxygen sites; onto each, one ⁴⁷Ti atom and one ⁴⁹Ti atom, told apart by their six and eight ESR peaks, are moved in turn by atom manipulation and read there under one microtip, the order set by a fair coin drawn before the first is moved. On each atom, the ESR tone on its first ESR peak, the two lines of the outermost nuclear step are read as the record reads features I and II, at the six fields of its four-Lorentzian fits, and f̄+ is the mean over those fields of the sum of the two positions. Observable: 𝔶hf = ln[f̄+(⁴⁹Ti)/f̄+(⁴⁷Ti)] − 𝔳N, with 𝔳N = ln[𝔤N(⁴⁹Ti)/𝔤N(⁴⁷Ti)] = (2.7 ± 0.2) × 10⁻⁴ from the two isotopes’ moments and spins measured in bulk, −0.78848 and −1.10417 nuclear magnetons, spins 5/2 and 7/2; for ⁴⁷Ti the deposited spectra give f̄+ = 131.9 ± 0.3 MHz. FDT: for purely density-coupled equilibrium observables a heavier isotope gives a larger Rs, a higher α and a larger response, opposite in sign to conventional reduced-mass scaling (I-⁠7). The density channel enters through the exterior compactness of the titanium nucleus as P-⁠3’s clamp, moved by the substitution through its 𝓜 at fixed pressure, one declared rf = 1.0 nm and packing: Δ ln αext = ln[𝓜(⁴⁹Ti)/𝓜(⁴⁷Ti)] = 0.04165 from the nuclear masses. The analysis reads the larger response as a larger hyperfine term per unit nuclear g-factor. f̄+, a splitting of the undriven configuration, is an equilibrium observable and not purely density-coupled: the channel of the two nuclear moments is 𝔳N, which the observable removes, and its other channels are the other terms of the sum δ ln O = Σi Si δ ln xi, each Si defined with the other channels’ variables held fixed. The density channel’s input sign is positive; the observable sign, sgn(∏ Si), is fixed once the sensitivities are established, and T-⁠3’s one-sided rules take it as positive on the analysis’s reading: T-⁠3 is a sign prediction. Comparator: each pair’s consensus departure, the hyperfine anomaly from the two nuclei’s distributions of magnetization and charge, the adatom’s mass-dependent zero-point term and Eq. (1)’s terms beyond first order, lies inside ±𝔠iso = ±0.002. Detection: the one-sided test of the values less 𝔠iso rejects upward at p ≤ 0.00135, of size at most 5/4096 wherever every pair’s departure lies in the interval. Exclusion: a density-channel contribution of 𝔥iso = 0.006 or more in the logarithm is excluded when the one-sided test of the values less 0.004 rejects downward at p ≤ 0.00135; otherwise the result is inconclusive.
  4. T-⁠4
    The outer resonance’s slope against the field departs upward in the same pairs, in the same reading. On each atom of T-⁠3’s sites, 𝔴 is the slope of a straight-line fit of fc against the applied field over the record’s seven fields, the tip’s term its offset; for ⁴⁷Ti the deposited spectra give 𝔴 = 7.88 ± 0.02 GHz/T. Observable: 𝔶g = ln[𝔴(⁴⁹Ti)/𝔴(⁴⁷Ti)]. The FDT input is T-⁠3’s, the electron’s closure read on the exterior atlas of the nucleus and the larger response read as a larger slope of the outer resonance, no channel removed; T-⁠4 is a sign prediction. Comparator: the consensus dependence of an adatom’s electronic g-factor on its isotope, its mass-dependent and zero-point terms, with Eq. (1)’s terms beyond first order, inside ±𝔠iso = ±0.002. The rules and the exclusion scale are T-⁠3’s.
  5. T-⁠5
    A driven nuclear step and its reverse, read shot by shot, are two settlements whose rates differ, where the consensus account gives both one matrix element. Twelve ⁴⁷Ti atoms under one microtip. A shot: the nuclear seating read by the single-shot method, the record’s Ref. 33, with the ESR tone on the first ESR peak and on the second in turn; the NMR tone on line I for a set time at a set amplitude; and the seating read again. Observable: 𝔶rev = ½[ln(𝔫b/𝔫a)−5/2 + ln(𝔫b/𝔫a)−3/2], with 𝔫a and 𝔫b the counts of shots ending in −5/2 and in −3/2 and the beginning seating as each logarithm’s subscript. A control shot has the tone at the record’s off-resonance 30.2 MHz, and the first value is read only where, of 800 control shots that begin in each seating, at least 0.97 end in it. On each atom, beforehand, the pulse time is the shortest at which the two beginnings’ ln(𝔫b/𝔫a) differ by less than 0.1, and the amplitude one from which a doubling at that time changes 𝔶rev by less than 0.05, each read to a counting standard error of 0.02; then shots are taken until 1600 end in one of the step’s two seatings, 800 that began in each. In the consensus account one matrix element serves a driven transition and its reverse, and a drive that outruns every other rate makes the two dwell fractions equal whatever the pump and the relaxation do: 𝔶rev = 0. FDT: the driven step from −5/2 to −3/2 and the driven step back are two settlements, each from the state it starts in, so their rates are not bound to that one matrix element (0.1a): 𝔶rev = ln(𝔯ab/𝔯ba) ≠ 0, with 𝔯ab and 𝔯ba the rates of the step and of the step back, an existence prediction, its sense unassigned; no rate of either settlement is written (O-⁠12). Comparator: 𝔶rev inside ±𝔠rev = ±0.2, which carries what the pump and the relaxation leave under the amplitude criterion, 0.05 × 4/3, what a change of seating before the reading and unequal chances of reading the two seatings leave, ln(1.03/0.97) = 0.06, and the tone’s off-resonant drive of line III, terms of one sign in every atom; the counting error of each value is symmetric, its standard error 2/√1600 = 0.05. Detection: the bounded test with 𝔠 = 𝔠rev. Exclusion: the exclusion test with 𝔥rev = 0.6; otherwise the result is inconclusive.

A T-⁠1 or T-⁠2 detection is read as the field P-⁠5 assigns to the helical geometry when the bounded test also holds, with the detection’s sign, on (4𝔶′ − 𝔶)/3, 𝔶′ being the contrast read at the same height with the bias and the ESR amplitude halved; the exclusion is read on that combination too. A T-⁠3 detection is read as the density channel when it stands with the interval recomputed from the two isotopes’ hyperfine anomaly measured in another configuration, the site’s calculated zero-point term and the exact diagonalisation of Eq. (1); a T-⁠4 detection when it stands with the interval recomputed from the sites’ measured changes between the two readings. A T-⁠5 detection is read as the difference of the two settlements when it stands with the amplitude and the pulse time doubled.

At each test’s test point the input in place and the input ablated give different decisions. With the bound at its ceiling and each of the twelve values at the test point, the bounded test sees twelve equal values 𝔥 − 𝔠; the largest mean that one sign flip among them leaves short of rejection is five-sixths of each, so the threshold is 𝔠 + 5(𝔥 − 𝔠)/6. For T-⁠1 and T-⁠2 it is 0.09 fcal, against a difference of 0.1 fcal between the input in place and ablated; for T-⁠5 it is 8/15 = 0.533, against 0.6. For T-⁠3 and T-⁠4, with the comparator at the interval’s upper end, the values stand at 0.008 with the input and 0.002 without it, and the residuals at 0.006 and 0 face the threshold 5𝔥iso/6 = 0.005.

Five tests and their comparators. Twist, T-⁠1 beside ⁴⁷Ti and T-⁠2 beside titanium without nuclear spin: twelve pair contrasts in units of fcal, each the input’s effect, ±𝔥tw = ±0.1 at the test point or 0 ablated, plus a term one atom or its place carries, signed by the hand coin, a drift between the two senses’ readings signed by the order coin, filled or open, and the leak, set by the slider, inside the ceiling ±0.04. Isotopes, T-⁠3 and T-⁠4: twelve pair differences 𝔶hf or 𝔶g, ⁴⁹Ti against ⁴⁷Ti, each the pair’s consensus departure inside ±𝔠iso = ±0.002, a site term and a reading drift signed by the order coin, and the density channel, 𝔥iso = 0.006 at the test point or 0 ablated. Two settlements, T-⁠5: twelve values of 𝔶rev, each the bounded term, one value for every atom set by the slider, the counting error of standard error 0.05, and the input, ±𝔥rev = ±0.6 at the test point or 0 ablated, the bounded part inside ±0.2. The decision panel draws the mean under every one of the 4096 sign assignments: the ten most extreme make the two-sided region, p ≤ 0.0027, and the five largest the one-sided region, p ≤ 0.00135; the bounded and exclusion tests repeat the test with every value shifted. Every scatter is seeded and illustrative, since the tests rest on sign symmetry and the declared bounds and on no variance estimate; the apparatus, settings and test points are the analysis’s design, not measurements in the source, and the test points instantiate effects, never derived values (P-⁠5, I-⁠7, 0.1a).

T-⁠1 to T-⁠5, P-⁠5, I-⁠7, 0.1a

Readings declined

Use 6 Data yes, interpretation not necessarily

Standard reading

The electron Zeeman splitting has contributions from the external magnetic field (B) and the magnetic field produced by the spin-polarized tip (Btip).

FDT reading

Both are one helical density gradient of the omnium where the electron’s closure sits, a twist, never two fields as entities (P-⁠5). The deposited slope and offset of the outer resonance are accepted in full.

At low field the eigenstates take the form of hybrid states, and the magnetoresistive readout is an electron spin projective measurement.

The record is read deterministically: the hybridization, in the analysis’s reading, a shared bivector grade, and the readout projection and phase fixation (I-⁠4). The low-field features and their absence at 200 mT are accepted in full.

The deposit’s population model behind the readout takes a scattering and its reverse to share each squared matrix element of one operator.

Each pumped or driven step is a settlement of the state it starts from, and a process run backward is never the mirror of the forward event (0.1a). The relative ESR peak heights are accepted in full; T-⁠5 is where the two readings part.

Determining the signs of the hyperfine and quadrupole interactions reveals the nature of the nuclear spin.

The signs are properties of the joined configuration, for there are no intrinsic particle masses or properties (I-⁠5). Both signs are accepted in full.

The negative quadrupole term prefers an in-plane nuclear charge distribution.

The term is the nucleus’s l = 2 moment, its skin against its own centre path reading the surrounding tide (I-⁠3a); a nucleus is one pattern, and what a probe reconstructs is its response, not a distribution of constituents inside a boundary (0.1b). The sign is accepted in full.

Modulation of the nuclear g-factor by an RF electric field in the junction is arguably weak, as nuclear spins are usually considered to be well shielded from electric fields by the electrons around the nucleus.

The electron’s closure and the nucleus are patterns of one medium, with no container distinct from its contents (0.1b). The argument rests on no measurement of the record, and its NMR lines in the MHz range at every field are accepted in full.

Convergence

Use 2 Same source, same data

FDT agrees with the measured record of general relativity and quantum mechanics without reservation. On the record’s own inputs and dictionary, its Eq. (1) with the fitted terms, FDT and the consensus calculation return the same line positions, and every position, sum, difference, crossing field, field at the nucleus and relay ratio written here from Eq. (1) is an identity on Eq. (1) and corroborates no invariant. The deposited spectra, refitted, recover the record’s data: six ESR peaks spaced by 132.2 ± 0.5 MHz, the two lines of one nuclear step summing to 131.9 ± 0.3 MHz beside the fitted 132.4 ± 0.4 MHz, line I falling over the seven fields at |𝔤N| = 0.36 ± 0.04 beside the record’s 0.37 ± 0.04, and the amplitude ratio of lines II and I rising with the ESR amplitude, 0.6 ± 0.2, 0.8 ± 0.1 and 0.9 ± 0.1 at 6, 12 and 19 mV. Every peak, line, term and sign the record reports is accepted in full.

The I-⁠1 pair evaluation is G𝓜₁𝓜₂/d² exactly on its declared domain, and the curvature the atom, its tip and its support carry is general relativity’s for the same stress tensor and data (I-⁠3): nothing is continued and nothing is corrected. Each test’s convergence value is its comparator’s: zero within the leak for T-⁠1 and T-⁠2, each pair’s consensus departure inside ±0.002 for T-⁠3 and T-⁠4, and a value inside ±0.2 for T-⁠5. FDT makes a divergence claim only where P-⁠5 supplies an additional source, I-⁠7 a constitutive input or 0.1a a changed observable dictionary, never through α, a chart or a branch tag alone. Where FDT, general relativity and quantum mechanics converge, FDT reproduces their results; where it declines their assumptions, here two fields as entities, probability amplitudes, a reverse step that mirrors the forward one and a nucleus walled off by its electrons, it is under no obligation to reproduce them.